Bedding Review

Wooly 3″ Organic Wool Topper VS Lift by Amerisleep Topper Comparison


Diving straight into the construction, the Wooly 3″ Organic Wool Mattress Topper boasts a simple yet luxurious design. It employs organic wool batting, known for its supportive cushioning and pressure point relief. The topper is encased in a lush organic cotton sateen fabric. On the flip side, the Lift by Amerisleep Mattress Topper is a testament to modern technology. It features a 3-inch layer of gel memory foam coupled with Amerisleep’s proprietary HIVE® technology, aiming for targeted support and pressure relief.


When it comes to comfort, the Wooly Topper offers a hotel pillowtop-like feel. Its organic wool batting offers a fluffy, cloud-like feel that makes a mattress noticeably softer. The Lift by Amerisleep Topper, with its gel memory foam and HIVE® technology, contours to your body, targeting specific areas for support and pressure relief. The choice here depends on whether you prefer a fluffy, soft feel (Wooly) or a more contouring, supportive experience (Amerisleep).

   Feel Change

As for the feel-change, both toppers substantially alter the feel of an existing mattress. The Wooly Topper can transform a firm mattress into a plush, cloud-like sleeping surface. The Lift by Amerisleep, with its HIVE® technology, provides an impression of sleeping “in” the mattress rather than “on” it due to the memory foam’s contouring effect.

  Cooling Capabilities

In terms of cooling, the Wooly Topper takes advantage of wool’s natural temperature regulation, keeping you comfortable in both warm and cool weather. Wool’s moisture-wicking properties may also reduce sweating. Conversely, the Lift by Amerisleep Topper includes an ultra-breathable cover, allowing heat to dissipate and keeping you cool. Both offer excellent cooling capabilities, although the natural properties of wool may give the Wooly Topper a slight edge.


Durability is a crucial factor in a topper’s long-term value. Wooly’s use of high-quality natural materials suggests a decent lifespan, although the exact durability is not specified. Amerisleep, however, confidently backs its Lift Topper with a 5-year warranty, assuring users of its durability.


The Wooly Topper and Lift by Amerisleep Topper are both premium options but with a significant price difference. The Wooly Topper, while luxurious and natural, comes at a higher price point, making it suitable for shoppers with a larger budget. The Lift by Amerisleep Topper, despite its advanced technology and long warranty, is considerably more affordable, offering better value for money.

In the end, the choice between the Wooly 3″ Organic Wool Mattress Topper and the Lift by Amerisleep Mattress Topper largely depends on personal preference and budget. If you value natural materials and a plush, soft feel, the Wooly Topper is a fantastic option. However, if you’re seeking advanced technology for targeted support, pressure relief, and a more affordable price, the Lift by Amerisleep Topper holds the upper hand.